CWA Section 316(b) Regulation
Power Plant Once-Through Cooling Regulation
The State Water Board staff is working on a draft statewide policy to implement section 316 (b) of the Clean Water Act that controls the harmful effects of once-through cooling water intake structures on marine and estuarine life. Since 1972, the Clean Water Act has required, in Section 316 (b), that the location, design, construction, and capacity of cooling water intake structures reflect the best technology available for minimizing adverse environmental impacts. In 2001, USEPA promulgated new regulations governing cooling water intake structures for new power plants (Phase I) and, three years later, regulations for existing power plants (Phase II).
On July 31, 2006 the State Water Board held an initial public scoping* meeting for a statewide once-through cooling water policy to implement USEPA Phase II requirements for existing power plants. Since that time, the regulatory landscape has changed. In July of 2007, the USEPA suspended the requirements of cooling water intake structures at Phase II existing facilities. In response, the State Water Board subsequently released a revised scoping document in March of 2008, and held public scoping meetings in May 2008. State Water Board staff has since been meeting with a panel of experts, which presented their final findings in August 2008 on questions related to the scoping document and development of the policy.
* California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires "scoping" as an early and open process for determining the scope of issues to be addressed and for identifying the significant issues related to a proposed action.
Tentative Timeline
State Water Board staff had hoped to have a draft Substitute Environmental Document (SED) for a proposed statewide policy on once-through cooling at coastal and estuarine power plants completed by the end of 2008. The draft SED will include a draft Policy, an environmental impacts assessment, discussion of issues and alternatives, and staff recommendations. However, due to staffing changes and contract delays, the projected release date for the draft SED has been extended to early 2009.
Available Documents (in descending chronological order):
Expert Review Panel Findings (August 2008):
The Expert Review Panel reviewed the scientific aspects of the proposed policy and provided final findings in August 2008 on questions related to the March 2008 Scoping Document.
- Final Responses
- Entrainment and Impingement Estimates (John Steinbeck, July 2008)
- Final Individual Member Comments
- Draft Responses
- Draft Individual Member Comments
State Water Board CEQA Scoping Meetings on May 8, 2008 in San Pedro and May 13, 2008 in Sacramento:
- Revised Notice
- March 2008 Scoping Document
- Comments - Deadline May 20, 2008 (noon)
- SWRCB Presentation, with Agenda
- Late California Energy Commission Comments to State Water Board
Symposium "Understanding the Environmental Effects of Once Through Cooling" on January 15 & 16, 2008, UC Davis University Club:
- Agenda, Abstracts and Speaker Biographies
- Presentations
- Eric Miller - Marine Fishes
- Elizabeth Strange - OTC Impact Assessment
- Jon Geller - Molecular ID
- Dan Pondella - Icthyoplankton King Harbor
- John Largier - Far Field Entrainment
- John Steinbeck - Assessing I&E Impacts
- Elizabeth Strange - Scaling Restoration
- Tim Mussen - Vibrating Fish Screens
- Tim Havey - Alt Cooling Systems Analysis
- John Maulbetsch - Issues Retrofitting Coastal Plants
- Matt Trask - Electric Reliability Study
- John Maulbetsch - Salt Water Cooling Towers
- Steve Saiz - State Water Board 316b Report
State Water Board CEQA Scoping Meeting on July 31, 2006 in Sacramento:
- Notice
- CEQA Scoping Document
- Comment Deadline Extended to September 15, 2006 (5pm)
- Comment Deadline Extended to September 25, 2006 (5pm)
- Comments
- Agenda
State Water Board Workshop on December 7, 2005 in Oakland
- Notice
- Revised Workshop Agenda
- Meeting Transcripts (Disclaimer: This transcript was made from a tape recording. The State Water Board does not guarantee the accuracy of this transcript.)
- Presentations
- Comments
State Water Board Workshop on September 26, 2005 in Laguna Beach
- Notice of Workshop
- Workshop Agenda
- Meeting Transcripts (Disclaimer: This transcript was made from a tape recording. The State Water Board does not guarantee the accuracy of this transcript.)
- Presentations
- Comments
Relevant Documents
- Electric Grid Reliability Impacts from Once-Through Cooling in California (Jones & Stokes Associates, April 2008)
- California's Coastal Power Plants: Alternative Cooling System Analysis (TetraTech, February 2008)
- Assessment of Once-Through Cooling System Impacts to California Coastal Fish and Fisheries (Electric Power Research Institute, December 2007)
- Issues Analysis of Retrofitting Once-Through Cooled Plants with Closed Cycle Cooling (Electric Power Research Institute, October 2007)
- 1975 Policy on the Use of Inland Waters for Powerplant Cooling - Includes Resolution 75-58
Disclaimer: All documents and drafts are accurate as of the date prepared or presented, but may not represent the most current thinking or data available. Older documents are presented here for purposes of history or context.
